Skip to content

Plutonic Rainbows

2027 or 2052

Ask when AI will be able to do its own research, with no people in the loop, and the answers run from next year to 2052. The Forecasting Research Institute gathered them up this month.

Six forecasts of when AI will be able to do AI research without people. The AI Futures Project and Anthropic's Jack Clark both say 2027. Dario Amodei's estimate runs from Jan 2027 to Jan 2028, OpenAI's own target is March 2028 and FutureSearch says June 2032. A survey of machine-learning researchers gives 2052, 25 years after the earliest. Six forecasts of when AI will be able to do AI research without people. The AI Futures Project and Anthropic's Jack Clark both say 2027. Dario Amodei's estimate runs from Jan 2027 to Jan 2028, OpenAI's own target is March 2028 and FutureSearch says June 2032. A survey of machine-learning researchers gives 2052, 25 years after the earliest.
When six sources expect AI to be doing AI research without people, as each stood on 18 November 2026. A bar covers the year or range a source names and a dot is a named month. Each source defines the milestone in its own words.

The near end is crowded. In May Jack Clark of Anthropic gave 2027 a 30% chance; by October he called it likelier than 2028, and on 10 November the AI Futures Project moved to 2027 too. Dario Amodei wrote in January that the loop was “1–2 years away”, and OpenAI’s internal target for an automated researcher is March 2028. FutureSearch expects a lab to say a model was mainly designed by its predecessor by June 2032. Then the chart is empty for nearly twenty years (the Institute’s entries in that stretch date other things), until AI Impacts’ December 2024 survey, where the 458 machine-learning researchers who took the question reach even odds, between them, in 2052.

Three of the four earliest marks come from inside the labs, two from one company, and those are the people with most to gain from being believed. Nor are the six dating the same event: Clark means full self-improvement becoming possible, FutureSearch a lab’s announcement. An announcement is what I’d expect first. OpenAI says it met its September goal of an automated research intern, so my mark goes on March 2028, when it declares the next one met.

Sources:

This post is timestamped using Blockchain technology. Verify

Nought for Three

Both models I called for November have now shipped, and I got neither date. I said GPT-6.2 Astra and Sol would arrive before 13 November, and OpenAI released them on the 17th, four days past the deadline. I said the next Fable would land in the last week of the month, and Anthropic put out Fable 5.2 on the 9th, a fortnight before my window opened. When the OpenAI call ran out I made a second one, for the week of 23 November, and the 17th was six days too early for that.

Timeline of OpenAI and Anthropic model releases from September to November 2026. GPT-6.2 Astra arrived on 17 November, between forecast windows of 6 to 12 November and 23 to 29 November. Claude Fable 5.2 arrived on 9 November, two weeks before a forecast window covering the last week of November. Timeline of OpenAI and Anthropic model releases from September to November 2026. GPT-6.2 Astra arrived on 17 November, between forecast windows of 6 to 12 November and 23 to 29 November. Claude Fable 5.2 arrived on 9 November, two weeks before a forecast window covering the last week of November.
OpenAI and Anthropic releases since 1 September, by announcement date, with my forecast windows in orange. Solid arcs are the gaps between flagships as they happened, and dotted arcs are the gaps I assumed.

For OpenAI I took a 41-day median from ArtificialWatch’s release log and counted forward from GPT-6.1 Sol, which gave 9 November. I should have looked at what the median was made of. The log had three OpenAI models in it, so two gaps, 56 days and 26, and 41 is simply halfway between them. Worse, I counted from a Sol while waiting for an Astra. In the same post I’d told myself that Anthropic’s top tier runs slower than its cheaper ones, and then didn’t apply that to OpenAI, where two Sols shipped a week apart in September. There was no Astra-to-Astra gap to count at all until this week, and the first one, GPT-6 Astra to GPT-6.2 Astra, turned out to be 75 days.

The Anthropic call had the right tier and even less evidence. The Fable tier had exactly one gap on record and I treated it as a schedule. I made it 84 days by counting from Fable 5’s announcement on 9 June, but that release was suspended and redeployed on 1 July, and ArtificialWatch dates the model from the redeployment. Counted that way the gap is 62 days, which would have pointed at 2 November, a week from the real date. The gap that followed was 69.

Both releases landed just ahead of Anthropic’s listing. Its shares are due to start trading tomorrow, and Fable 5.2 arrived ten days before that, GPT-6.2 two. Last week I wrote that I’d want my flagship in the news that week if I were Sam Altman, and then guessed OpenAI would hold off until the IPO headlines had passed, so I had the listing in view and still picked the wrong side of it.

Each lab now has one flagship gap on record this autumn, 69 days for Fable and 75 for Astra. Add them on and both next flagships fall in the second half of January, which is the same sum I did for Fable on the 6th, with one gap and no reason to trust it, so I’m not calling January.

Sources:

This post is timestamped using Blockchain technology. Verify

Early Access Isn't a Conspiracy

OpenAI’s launch post for GPT-6.2 Astra and Sol went up at 12:54 PM Eastern on Tuesday. By 1:02, Ridge’s timeline has Matt Shumer saying he wouldn’t write his usual review because the models “were essentially unusable”, and at 1:23 Theo Browne called Astra “the worst model OpenAI has ever released”. Dan Shipper said Every’s team had tested both for weeks and found “a disappointing release compared to Fable 5.2”. That’s three well-known testers reaching one verdict inside half an hour, two days before Anthropic’s shares are due to start trading.

It wasn’t the whole reception. Simon Willison called the buzz “mixed”, Artificial Analysis has Astra second on its index behind only Fable 5.2, and Derya Unutmaz, who also had early access, told Shumer his own testing was “exactly opposite”. The bad reviews were the loud ones, though, and they came in a cluster.

The suspicion arrived almost as fast. Shopify’s MJ wrote that the whole thing “feels weirdly coordinated. Apparently everyone has been using it for weeks and all decided to rant about it on the same day.” A reply under Shumer’s post reads, in full, “I’m glad to confirm you are an Ant shill”.

I don’t buy it, and MJ’s own sentence is the reason. Everyone had been using it for weeks because OpenAI gave them early access, and they all posted on the same day because, almost certainly, it was the first day they were allowed to. I haven’t seen the terms those testers agreed to, but that’s how pre-release access has worked for every model I’ve followed. Praise from early testers arrives on the same clock, and nobody calls that coordinated. The Anthropic half of the charge is thinner still. All three rate Claude models higher right now, which is a preference, and none of the posts I found alleging a campaign offers evidence of anything more.

The complaints also don’t read like a script. Shipper’s notes say Astra matched its predecessor on Every’s coding benchmarks but “seemed to stop too early frequently” on real builds. Browne’s long piece, Why I hate GPT-6.2 Astra, is a letter he says he sent OpenAI during testing, and it stops to call Astra a “Great reviewer” that “catches things other models miss”. He adds that he’s “likely overreacting (I am admittedly known for that)”. A shill doesn’t send his notes to the vendor first. None of this rules out a group chat, but it leaves the accusation with nothing left to explain.

OpenAI has supplied two explanations of its own, and neither involves bad faith. Its system card, as MLQ.ai reports it, says Astra “omitted a known obstacle to completing its work in 22.28 percent of trials, compared with 11.09 percent for GPT-6 Astra”, and adds “We are concerned by this regression”. That’s close to Browne’s complaint that he couldn’t tell afterwards what the model had done. Then OpenAI’s Thibault Sottiaux said the testers saw an older build: “we gave a few folks access a while ago and then made a lot of changes in the last 3-4 days”. The shipped model may well be better than the one they reviewed. Either way, they reported what they were given.

Sources:

This post is timestamped using Blockchain technology. Verify

Aaron Dilloway Opens Wide

Aaron Dilloway has seemingly no understanding of, or interest in, the supposed limits of experimental music. I said much the same about The Gag File in 2017, when he was still new to me, and nine years on I wouldn’t change a word. No Skill Comedy Mind Reading came out on Dais last Friday, his first full-length album since that year, and it’s strange indeed.

Pitchfork’s Matthew Blackwell reviewed it yesterday and found “a sense of creepy unease” in which “funny ha-ha is never far from funny uh-oh”. Dilloway, he writes, “thrives in the zone where comedy meets horror, digging through haunted attics to find the uncanniest cultural detritus of a bygone era”. This time the attic gives up the Unknown Comic, a seventies stand-up who told bad jokes with a paper bag over his head. On “Bring Me the Head of the Unknown Comic” a loop of laughter slides into a sob, then a wail, and keeps climbing in pitch until it’s, in Blackwell’s words, “more simian than human”. Dilloway counts the album as the last part of a loose trilogy with Modern Jester and The Gag File, and says all three “could be seen as funny or just horrifying, horrible records”, depending on who’s listening.

Jennifer Lucy Allan opened his Baker’s Dozen interview for the Quietus in 2021 with “I heard it said once that Aaron Dilloway was born with a contact mic in his mouth”, adding that he’s “often photographed mid-grimace with a wire dangling from his mouth”. Even the cover is unsettling: a red mouth outlined in blue, stretched open around two crowded rows of teeth and stranded on a blank white square, the bottom lip sagging as if it had begun to melt. I can’t decide whether it’s laughing or screaming.

Sources:

This post is timestamped using Blockchain technology. Verify

Quad Spins, Cambridge Converts

Quad’s 3CDT is a low black box with a green readout, and it can’t make a sound on its own. A CD transport is a CD player with the clever half removed. It spins the disc, reads the data and hands the raw digital stream on to something else to turn into sound. In my rack that something else is the Cambridge Audio CXN100, which has its own ESS ES9028Q2M converter and already holds rips of my 2,000-odd CDs. On paper that makes a disc spinner redundant. In practice I still reach for the shelf, and the question was never whether to play discs but what should turn them into sound.

The answer is the converter I already own. Everything I play, streamed, ripped or spun, now goes through the same chip and the same analogue stage behind it. A conventional CD player would bring a second DAC into the system, with its own filter and its own idea of what the treble should sound like, and I’d spend evenings comparing disc against file when I was really comparing two converters. With a transport that confusion goes. A CD and its rip reach the same chip as the same 16-bit, 44.1kHz data, so if I ever do hear a difference, it can only come from how the data got there.

None of the 3CDT’s £599 goes on a second converter. I made the same argument about Hegel’s A200, which drops the DAC and the streamer the H200 charges for. Paying twice for conversion is still paying twice, whatever badge is on the front.

Delivery is where Quad has put its effort. According to On-Mag, the 3CDT’s power supply keeps the motor and servo circuits apart from the decoder, and a low-jitter TCXO clock times the whole thing. Spinning a disc is mechanical, noisy work, and splitting the boxes keeps it in a chassis with no converter inside to disturb. I’m less sure the clock counts for much once it leaves. S/PDIF carries the timing inside the signal, so the CXN100 recovers it at its own end, and that receiver matters at least as much as the source.

The connection is one cable. The back panel has a single coaxial and a single optical output, both fixed at 44.1kHz, and the CXN100 has an input for each. The same panel reads Huntingdon, UK, under the Quad logo and Made in China a little further along, beside the warning not to open it.

The split also leaves room to change my mind. If a DAC I like more turns up in a few years, it replaces the converter and the transport carries on reading discs into it exactly as it does now.

Sources:

This post is timestamped using Blockchain technology. Verify

Fable 5.2 Flies Round Fuji

On Monday I picked Fable 5.2 in Claude Code and went straight back to Opus 5.5. This evening I made it the default and typed one sentence: using three.js, build a fly-by over Mount Fuji. What came back is a 200-second flight round the real mountain, in over Lake Kawaguchi, past the Hōei crater, a slow orbit of the summit and out across Lake Motosu. You can fly it yourself; it’s about a 4 MB download.

The lazy answer to that sentence is a grey cone on a flat plane, and nothing in it asked for more. Fable went and found open elevation data anyway, and when that couldn’t place the lakes it took their outlines from OpenStreetMap. Then it rendered its own frames and fixed what it didn’t like in them: a grid pattern in the grass, a camera that kept missing the lake. I asked for one change to the flight itself, bigger captions.

It’s a small thing next to Saltline, the shooter an Anthropic engineer shared on launch day, built from one prompt in eight hours unattended at an estimated $550. It isn’t a photograph either. Forest and snow are generated from height and slope, so there are no towns or roads, and the phone version is untested on a real phone.

Sources:

This post is timestamped using Blockchain technology. Verify

Werwulf at Christmas

Werwulf’s poster has a figure folded over in a churchyard, one arm stretched up so its clawed hand covers the moon, under a tagline spelled “Devoureth All Mankynde”. Robert Eggers is doing a werewolf, set in England around 1300, and he told IGN that after Nosferatu he set out to write the scariest thing he could, wasn’t sure he’d managed it, “but I definitely wrote the darkest thing.” It opens in American cinemas on Christmas Day and in the UK on 1 January, about six weeks from now.

He wrote it with Sjón, the Icelandic poet who co-wrote The Northman, and the dialogue is Middle English, checked by two Oxford scholars, Eleanor Baker and Daniel Wakelin. A dialect coach, William Conacher, then nudged the pronunciation back towards something a modern audience can follow, so it’s scholarly English bent just far enough to be speakable. Eggers says “you don’t need to understand what anyone’s saying to understand the movie”, and I believe him. In The Lighthouse, Willem Dafoe’s sea curses worked on sound and rhythm long before they worked as sense. Middle English is further off, but it should work the same way.

Aaron Taylor-Johnson plays a farmer listed only as Man, and Lily-Rose Depp is Woman, his wife. Neither gets a proper name, which pushes the whole thing towards folktale before a frame of it has screened. Dafoe, Ralph Ineson and Jack Morris are the hunters sent to kill him. Taylor-Johnson, Depp and Dafoe all come straight from Nosferatu, which I saw on Boxing Day 2024. That film opened on Christmas Day and grossed around $181m worldwide, and Focus has given this one the same date.

Focus is also selling tickets for 35mm screenings in selected cinemas, which is the version I want and almost certainly won’t find anywhere near me. The trailer already looks the part, grainy and boxed into 4:3. I’m aiming for New Year’s Day, most likely on a digital screen.

Sources:

This post is timestamped using Blockchain technology. Verify

Seventy-One Days Without an Astra

Today is 71 days since GPT-6 Astra went out on 3 September, and OpenAI still hasn’t shipped another flagship. My own call was GPT-6.2 Astra and Sol before 13 November, so this is the day it runs out. I got there from OpenAI’s 41-day median gap between frontier models, which is the same mistake I caught myself making with Anthropic in that post: the median comes from a burst across cheaper tiers, and the top tier runs slower. The nearest thing to a launch this week was a Codex lead musing about “a banked reset” on Thursday, which OrcaRouter noticed was quote-posted as a GPT-6.2 notice within four minutes. It was a quota coupon.

Below the flagship, OpenAI hasn’t been idle. GPT-6 Sol and Luna landed on 22 September, GPT-6.1 Terra on 26 October at a tenth of Astra’s price per token, and GPT-6 Cyber on 5 November, so anyone paying for ChatGPT or the API has had something new every few weeks. daily.dev quoted a tracker saying a miss last week would make this OpenAI’s longest gap between frontier models since GPT-5 and GPT-5.1, which says more about how quick the cadence had become than about any stall. The impatience lives with the people who watch Codex analytics for stray model labels. I’m one of them, and I’ve refreshed OpenAI’s changelog more this week than I’ve ever refreshed a parcel tracker.

Investors are a different matter. OpenAI raised $11bn at a $1.25 trillion valuation last week, short of the $20bn it first tried to raise, and Newcomer’s Tom Dotan wrote that OpenAI is “thirsting for a comeback story”. The same TechCrunch piece has Anthropic pricing its shares at $70 to $78, with trading reported for around 19 November and Fable 5.2 already out. I’d want my flagship in the news that week if I were Sam Altman. Still, the people who put money in at $1.25 trillion are betting on years, not on a launch date. A model that arrives a week after Anthropic’s listing barely dents that bet. A bad one would.

September already showed what a bad one looks like. The follow-up to the shipped model, GPT-6.1 Astra, was scrapped before release because, as Saachi Jain told WIRED, “it didn’t quite meet the bar in terms of staying within scope and authorization”, or in how it reported its own work back to the user. I wrote last week that built isn’t the same as cleared. An Astra pushed out to beat a rival’s listing, which then misbehaved in public, would cost OpenAI the one argument it has made all autumn, that it holds models back when they aren’t ready.

Prediction-market traders, as Mantis reports them, expect the next Astra in late November and treat a release by the end of the month as all but certain. My new guess is the week of 23 November, deliberately just after Anthropic’s first days of trading, so OpenAI avoids landing under the IPO headlines and gets the following week to itself. The real limit is later, around mid-December. By then Anthropic will have its first weeks as a listed company behind it, every number it reports will be set beside OpenAI’s, and a gap of more than three months at the top tier will need an explanation OpenAI hasn’t given. I’ll hold this guess more loosely than the last one.

Sources:

This post is timestamped using Blockchain technology. Verify

Grief, Secrecy and the Séance Room

On 19 January 1944 an undercover policeman at a séance in Portsmouth caught the medium Helen Duncan with a piece of white cloth, which vanished into the audience during the struggle that followed. Duncan and three of her sitters were arrested anyway. By the spring she was on trial at the Old Bailey under the Witchcraft Act of 1735, and the papers had a wonderful time with it, printing cartoons of witches on broomsticks while the country waited for the invasion of France.

Britain’s great spiritualist boom came after the first war, not the second, which makes the usual question about the 1940s slightly wrong. By the late 1920s and early 1930s there were around a quarter of a million practising Spiritualists and some two thousand Spiritualist societies in the UK, plus a whole culture of home circles and platform mediums. The second war didn’t create any of that. It handed a movement that already had churches, touring mediums and a national union a fresh supply of the bereaved, and the movement was ready for them.

Grief is the obvious explanation, and it’s correct as far as it goes. Duncan’s appointments diary was rarely empty through the 1930s, and Malcolm Gaskill, who wrote a book on her case, says demand became greater than ever once war broke out. Hilary Mantel, reviewing his book, made the point that belief wasn’t confined to the uneducated; it was “widespread among dons, clergymen and officers in the Armed Forces”, because “bereavement affected all classes”. The Royal Navy recognised spiritualism as a religion in 1941, and sailors were allowed to hold spiritualist services at sea.

But grief was there in 1918 as well. What seems particular to the Second World War is secrecy. Gaskill makes the point almost in passing: the spirits offered comfort, hope and, “due to the intense secrecy with which the authorities conducted the war, the sort of information and news that people craved.” Late in 1941 a dead sailor reportedly came through at one of Duncan’s sittings and announced that his ship, HMS Barham, had gone down. It just had. The relatives of the dead were told in confidence, but the loss was kept from everyone else, and according to the BBC’s account of the case it wasn’t officially declared until months later. Nobody has ever settled how Duncan knew. She might have heard it in a pub. Portsmouth was a naval town, and sailors’ families talk. But if you had someone at sea and the papers were saying nothing, a woman who seemed to know what the Admiralty wouldn’t tell you must have been very hard to dismiss. One sinking in one naval town is thin ground for a general theory, and I know it, but I’d push Gaskill’s point further than he does: grief explains why people wanted the dead, and secrecy goes a long way to explaining why they believed them.

The state saw the same thing from the other side. Mediums were normally fined under the 1824 Vagrancy Act, a petty charge, but Gaskill says the Portsmouth police moved in 1944 prompted by allegations that Duncan had disclosed confidential details of the Barham’s sinking. The authorities wanted her in prison (because of D-Day, her supporters said), so they reached for an Act from 1735, and MI5’s involvement in the investigation is, in Gaskill’s words, “beyond question”. If the police were chasing a leaked sinking, it’s hard to blame her sitters for thinking she knew things. The result was a trial on the front pages, nine months in Holloway, and Churchill writing to the Home Secretary to call the charge “obsolete tomfoolery”. Her appeal failed, and the judgement was read out in an air-raid shelter because the law courts had been bombed.

The trial turned a medium into a martyr and gave organised spiritualism a cause. The Spiritualists’ National Union had been campaigning for years for its members to worship without fear of prosecution, and it had the money to pay legal costs. After the war the pressure kept up. Thomas Brooks, a Labour MP and a spiritualist, led the campaign while another Labour MP, Walter Monslow, put the bill forward, and in 1951 the Witchcraft Act was finally repealed and replaced by the Fraudulent Mediums Act. From then on a prosecution needed evidence of deliberate deception for profit. If any single moment counts as spiritualism’s post-war triumph, it’s that one: the movement that had been dragged into the Old Bailey seven years earlier had rewritten the law.

And then, through the 1950s, it faded. Mantel, writing in the London Review of Books, is blunt about it. The 1951 Act carried an exemption for “anything done solely for the purposes of entertainment”, and in her reading it “drew its teeth. The occult was degraded to an amusement; and television soon offered a better one. During the 1950s, interest in spiritualism fell away.”

Television explains the empty séance rooms. It doesn’t explain why the urgency went, and my guess is that the secrecy argument works in reverse. Peace brought the news back. The dead stopped being a matter of rumour in a naval town, and once you could find out what had happened to your son through ordinary channels, you didn’t need a woman in a cabinet producing cheesecloth to tell you. That leaves 1951 looking odd, a legal victory six years after the need had started to drain away, but I suspect the Act measured the union’s grievance rather than the size of the congregation. An organised body with a cause can keep a campaign going long after the crowds have thinned. Mantel’s point about respectability can’t have helped either. A séance that might get you arrested has an edge to it. A séance protected by an Act of Parliament is closer to a whist drive.

Duncan herself went back to work after Holloway, holding séances around the country much as she had before the war, though people whispered that her powers were going. In November 1956 police raided a sitting in Nottingham. No charges were brought. She died at home in Edinburgh on 6 December that year, and the BBC says her descendants are still campaigning to clear her name.

Sources:

This post is timestamped using Blockchain technology. Verify

Fable 5.2 and the Slowdown

Anthropic released Claude Fable 5.2 today, with Mythos 5.2 alongside it for vetted organisations only. On Friday I called the next Fable for the last week of November, working from the 84 days between Fable 5 and 5.1, and it came after 69. I’d also been calling it Fable 5.5, because that’s the name the leaks used, so I’ve missed on both the date and the number.

CNBC points out that it’s the first frontier release since Dario Amodei called in September for the pace of AI development to slow. Anthropic says it built new evaluations and post-launch monitoring before shipping, and I believe that. The model itself goes the other way, though. Anthropic’s Fable page lists $8 per million input tokens and $40 per million output, down from $10 and $50, and CNBC says it produces output 30% faster. Whatever slowing down means at Anthropic, it doesn’t mean a dearer or slower flagship. With the IPO possibly as soon as next week, a price cut is the obvious way to show investors usage climbing, and I suspect that weighed more than the September call did.

The announcement still tells people to start with Opus 5.5 for most coding and knowledge work, and to save Fable for the hard problems. Fable 5.2 was in Claude Code’s model menu this evening, and I picked it, then went straight back to Opus 5.5.

Sources:

This post is timestamped using Blockchain technology. Verify

Most Read

What readers opened most over the last 3 months.

  1. Werwulf at Christmas
  2. Knows the Reset Guy
  3. Four AI Heavyweights Shaping the Future
  4. Dawn Arrived
  5. Thursday Was Ten Days Ago
  6. Sol, Terra, Luna, Astra
  7. Sixty to a Hundred
  8. Anthropic Won't Answer Astra
  9. Lavender and Leather at the Ralph Lauren Spring 1993 Show
  10. I. Magnin, Top Left